What a smoother Ocarina of Time remake takes away
Francisco Dominguez interviews designers and researchers about what is lost when the Ocarina of Time remake strips out the original's accidental friction: the chatty owl, the insistent fairy, the awkward camera and the Water Temple, whose designer has long regretted it. Max Nichols, a Zelda historian and former Bungie and Epic designer, finds the remake noticeably easier and traces that to modern Nintendo's attitude to friction, which he calls "the most basic unit of a videogame."
Nichols argues that people mistake quality-of-life changes for progress, when they are design choices with their own trade-offs. Dominguez frames the removals the same way, as a trade rather than a pure upgrade.
CounterpointPlayers who see the owl, the fairy and the Water Temple as plain flaws would say removing them simply serves the game, and that nostalgia for old annoyances is not a design argument.
Previously: Polygon argued the remake's child-era half suits young kids as a first Nintendo game. — Sunday November 15 edition.