Big Walk's AI admission could cost indies a GOTY slot
Polygon's Oli Welsh argues that 2025, when Clair Obscur, Hades 2 and Hollow Knight: Silksong were each nominated for both Game of the Year and Best Independent Game at The Game Awards, was an outlier. All three were huge sellers, and the awards' growing international jury tends to disadvantage indies that can't afford wide localization. This year's contenders (Big Walk, Mina the Hollower, Zero Parades, Mewgenics) haven't matched that scale. A weak GOTY slate still leaves a path for a critical darling, and Welsh rates Big Walk and Mina the Hollower, both with 90-plus Metacritic scores, as the best candidates.
House House's admission that generative AI wrote some of Big Walk's code will probably rule it out of the IGF and the Indie Game Awards. Welsh thinks the broader Game Awards jury is less likely to care. The news arrived late in the two-step nomination process, though, so offended jurors would have to actively remove nominations they had already made. He concludes it hurts Big Walk without necessarily sinking it, and that a AAA title such as Control Resonant or 007 First Light may benefit.
CounterpointThe indie-specialist jurors who have pledged not to vote for games that use generative AI would reject the premise that scale matters: they argue any such use should disqualify a game, however little code was involved.
Previously: Polygon defended House House's Big Walk over its LLM use, while a group of Indie Game Festival jurors pledged not to vote for games using gen-AI. — Sunday November 15 edition.